Ranking Human Pleasures – what is really good, TOV, our mission

What is really good – tov? Humans have been gifted with responsibility that other life forms don’t have. We have the ability to elevate ourselves and be custodians to what has been given to us.

Levels – lowest to highest, what is uniquely human ranks higher

  1. If an animal would have the same pleasure it is not lofty, anything instinctive, physical, carnal (food, sex, being petted (haha), etc.). Just because it feels good or makes you “happy”, doesn’t mean it ranks high. Enjoying these types of pleasures are “gross” – “pleasure in physical and corporeal things in general, for these are simply animal pleasures. An animal is attracted to whatever it in­stinctively considers satisfying, and—oblivious of any other form of good but this—is drawn to it.” These types of pleasure become addictive to the smaller self, the animal self. “even indulgence in the per­missible, when he seeks pleasure in enjoyments and luxuries beyond the necessities of living (is not good).” Not being moderate, overindulging 
  2. Sweet voice (music?) delighting in music.    Delighting in man made things? delighting in the arts, beauty, or delighting in creating – in that state of flow,

  3.  Traits from character – doing acts of kindness in order – generic (ranks lower – natural love A lion protects her cubs.) than doing something specific for someone with purpose and intellect involved.  Also lower if this is your natural inclination, versus something you have to work at doingWhen man conducts himself with, and derives pleasure from, emotional acts alone without the guid­ance of intellect, then he is similar to an animal. All of man’s emotions and traits must accord with the dictates of intellect.  Abraham’s example: This was his ultimate purpose in generosity. His generos­ity was not instinctive but purposeful, to bring mankind close to G-d by this means.

“Pleasures may be classified from inferior to superior: pleasure in delicious food and similar bodily enjoyments are the lowliest and are animalistic pleasures; delight in music; pleasure ensuing from purposeful intellectually driven emotions, ben­efiting the worthy, and when appropriate, even to the un­ deserving.”

4. Intellectual delights – comprehending a subject under study.

‘This is the finest, the truest, and the most exalted of delights (provided the idea it­ self is good and valid, for if the study is evil per re, then it would be included among those things forbidden to engage in). Man, the select of creation, should find his supreme delight in matters of the spirit, particularly in intellect. His soul ought to delight specifically in this, for this—the intellect that was given him and the “intelligent soul” that he possesses—is his unique quality above all creatures.”

Every creature in this world has a specific mission, which is its purpose. Its fulfillment is realized when it ascends to a state higher than its own.^’ The vegetable becomes assimilated in the animal; the animal becomes one with the human;“ the human is fulfilled when his spirit ascends and becomes one with the spiritual that is above him.

5. Spiritual delights – Studying the word of God – In this manner the soul of man can ascend, through binding and merging itself with the Divine wisdom.

“Supernal chochmah is the most hidden of all. It is unknown, and is not revealed” {Zohar 1:141b). This is the attribute of chochmah as it is with­ in keter, or more precisely in arich anpin, the outer dimension of keter.
The fact that the soul of man is of such sublime root should propel him to interest and occupy himself in mat­ters of the spirit and intellect.”

Nietzsche says blessed is the man who eats the lion, but not the man eaten by the lion…. eaten by our animal drives…

There is another advantage in this knowledge of the Inner Torah, and that is its effect on the person. Although this knowledge is limited to knowledge of His existence,^’ none­ theless, his mind does conceive and attain knowledge ofthe ex­ istence of the spiritual.^^ The spiritual becomes palpable, as it were, within his soul; he becomes bound up with it, attached to it, and as a result he transcends his own physical nature, and attains a state of tefmement and spirituality. This attainment is inward and personal, both within his own self and also ex­ ternally, in reference to all his interests and activities. They all become more refined and spiritual; they are not bound up with the physical at all, and they rise above awareness of self.

This is one of the most important things I have ever read. Bind yourself, it manifests both inwardly and externally – in interests and what we seek to do, how we can bring value to those around us. We must rise above our small selves – constantly examining our actions. Who/what do our words, deeds, actions serve? 

It goes without saying that his piety is not evident to another, and by no means would he consider doing something to im­press anyone.

Man, possessing an intelligent soul and a G-dly soul, must find his pleasure in Torah study; the fulfillment of every be­ ing is its elevation to a higher stage; through study of the Re­vealed Torah man unites with G-d’s wisdom and will; through study of Chasidus he binds himself with their inwardness, and becomes refined in everything.

revealed (outer) aspect and a concealed (inner) one

Mind can justify anything, Power of the mind

The mind – the sharpest tool we have, can be used for ultimate good, ultimate evil.

No limit to what the mind can explain and rationalize away. If we are so smart, why do we do such foolish things? Rabbi Ari asks. Because of our mind, we can look at a choice, a choice of action – look at it know it’s bad, destructive – but with our mind we can say, “this is why it makes sense.” We have a the power to use the mind for destructive behavior.

Human condition – we think of our mind as an ally, but the same assets can be our greatest enemy.

Overcoming Folly – Kabbala and psychology, how to catch ourselves when we are using our minds in an unhealthy way. Origins 1903 – 5th Chabad Rebbe

Entry point through Scripture “A wellspring will go forth from the House of God and shall water the valley of Shittim” (Joel 4:18). Shittim – folly, turning away from the path truth (or rational path), or doing something foolish

“One does not commit a sin, unless the spirit of folly enters him.” VERY POWERFUL

Unhealthy behavior – not entirely emotional or instinctive, but we use thoughts to make ourselves feel comfortable with the uncomfortable.

If we were thinking with our “right” minds, with our clear minds, we wouldn’t do unhealthy things. It’s our own mental gymnastics that explains why things aren’t so bad… It’s our inclination that seduces our mind.” The logic is crooked.” Rabbi Ari

We do the contortion to make the negative, obsessive, additive behavior seem okay… the mistakes we make – spirit of folly to take over, and get off the path of rational thinking. Evil inclination, get our minds on board, we tell ourselves – just this one time with foolish justifications and rationalizations… Get past barriers with our thinking…

(etymology of crooked – cunning)

Overcoming Folly explores a number of rationalizations, stories we tell ourselves…because of this, I deserve… what we tell ourselves to get into negative situations. Understanding how our mind gets us there will  help us climb out of those thought patterns that lead us down a negative, destructive path.

Hebrew word sattan (yetzer hara – inside of us, inner voice that tries turn us away, pivot from the rational, healthy path to a negative path, it pivots once, then shames you — evil prosecuting angle/force on high) – means to turn away from the proper path.

We have to catch ourselves by thinking rationally (healthy), knowing the patterns of irrational (unhealthy) thoughts. Only then, can we redirect ourselves.

Key to that is knowing the patterns of the irrational thoughts – spirit of folly –

Bad behavior is not just emotional, but it includes thinking in an irrational way, but make ourselves believe it’s rational. The moment we think clear minded – with clarity, then pull back from the negative choices, mind is always leading the actions – mind is paving the way… so must think in non contorted way.

Being Holy – separate yourself even from what is permissible – making sure you are responding and not reacting, overdoing.

What should our focus be on, what pleasures should we be thinking about? Where should our head, heart, thoughts be…

Self control and discipline is a biblical value (Rabbi Ari’s grandfather’s story – only eating what he needed).

“Man’s intention is whatever he does should be “for the sake of Heaven.”

The beginning of indulgence into lower pleasure – desirable to the eye – looks to us good and attractive, the rest follows, do not be lead astray after your heart and your eyes – eyes see, heart desires, get excited by look, sound – not thinking clearly …first story, that looks good. Saw, interpreted, desired in the mind.

1st doorway into sin, or getting off the right path is going after something that is attractive, only because it looks good, seems good, looks attractive. 

1st folly – it’s attractive.